Finding the right tenant is essential for maintaining the value and security of your property. Even in Massachusetts, where the median rent is notably 52% higher than the US average, finding the right tenant involves more than just choosing someone with the financial means to pay this premium. It requires careful consideration of various factors to ensure a reliable and responsible occupancy. 

This article provides ten practical tips for identifying the best tenant for your apartment, ensuring a harmonious and profitable rental experience.

1. Understand Massachusetts Tenant Screening Laws

In Massachusetts, landlords must navigate a set of specific laws that regulate the tenant screening process. These laws are designed to protect both the landlord and potential tenants from discrimination and privacy breaches. As a landlord, you should familiarize yourself with these regulations to ensure your screening methods are not only effective but also lawful. This includes understanding what can legally be asked in applications and interviews and how to handle background checks. Adhering to these laws not only protects you from potential legal issues but also assures tenants that they are entering into a fair and respectful rental agreement.

2. Use a Compliant Tenant Screening Platform

Utilizing a tenant screening platform that complies with Massachusetts tenant screening laws, as mentioned earlier, is a vital step in finding the right tenant. These platforms offer a range of checks, including credit scores, criminal history, past evictions, and verification of employment and income. By using a service that respects state-specific screening laws, landlords can obtain necessary information without violating tenant rights. This thorough vetting process helps identify candidates who are financially responsible and likely to be reliable renters while also maintaining a standard of fairness and legal compliance.

3. Check for Financial Stability

Financial stability is a cornerstone of a reliable tenant. In Massachusetts, where rents are high, ensuring that potential tenants have a steady income that is at least three times the monthly rent is a practical standard. This financial assessment can be accomplished by requesting recent pay stubs or tax returns. Assessing this aspect of a tenant’s application helps ensure that they can comfortably afford the rent without financial strain, which in turn increases the likelihood of consistent, timely payments.

4. Evaluate Rental History

A prospective tenant’s rental history can offer deep insights into their reliability and behavior as renters. Contacting previous landlords can reveal if the tenant was timely with rent payments, maintained the property well, and adhered to the rental agreement. Negative feedback, such as a history of evictions or significant property damage, serves as a red flag, whereas positive feedback can reassure you of the tenant’s suitability. This step is essential in building a comprehensive understanding of who the tenant is beyond their application and interview.

5. Conduct Interviews

Personal interviews are an invaluable part of the tenant screening process. They provide an opportunity to meet potential tenants face-to-face and assess qualities that aren’t visible on paper, such as their demeanor, honesty, and how well they might fit into the property community. This interaction also allows landlords to clarify any aspects of the tenant’s application or discuss the rules and expectations of the property. Effective communication during this stage can help in making a final decision and establishing a positive landlord-tenant relationship.

6. Be Clear About Your Rules

Setting clear expectations from the outset is fundamental to a successful landlord-tenant relationship. As a landlord in Massachusetts, where housing laws and tenant rights are stringently observed, it’s crucial for you to ensure that tenants are fully aware of all property rules before they move in. These rules might include policies on pets, smoking, and alterations to the apartment. Being transparent about your rules helps prevent misunderstandings and ensures that you attract tenants who are willing to comply with your terms. This clarity not only facilitates smoother day-to-day operations but also minimizes the potential for disputes, which can be time-consuming and costly to resolve.

7. Require a Reasonable Security Deposit

Collecting a security deposit is standard practice, serving as a safeguard against potential damages or unpaid rent. In Massachusetts, the amount of this deposit is regulated by law and typically should not exceed one month’s rent. Ensuring that the deposit amount is reasonable and within legal limits not only secures your property financially but also promotes fairness and trust with prospective tenants. It’s important to handle these deposits according to state laws, such as keeping them in a separate interest-bearing account and providing proper documentation to the tenant. This approach protects both parties and helps maintain a professional relationship.

8. Consider a Longer Lease

Offering a longer lease can be advantageous for both landlords and tenants. For landlords, it reduces turnover, which can be both costly and time-consuming. For tenants, a longer lease provides housing stability and the chance to establish a longer-term home. This arrangement can be particularly appealing in a competitive rental market, where finding a good apartment can be challenging. By proposing longer lease terms, you can attract tenants who are looking for stability, which often translates to fewer problems and a more consistent rental income over time.

9. Promote Your Property Effectively

Effective promotion is key to attracting a broad pool of potential tenants. This involves more than just listing the rental price and location; it requires a strategic approach to marketing. High-quality photos and detailed descriptions of the property are essential. Highlight features that set your property apart, like recent renovations, amenities, or a great neighborhood. Utilize various channels for advertising, such as online rental platforms, social media, and even traditional methods like flyers in local establishments. A well-marketed property not only draws more interest but can also attract higher-quality tenants.

10. Maintain a Professional Attitude

Maintaining professionalism throughout the renting process cannot be overstated. This includes every interaction with potential and current tenants, from the wording in your ads to communication during lease negotiations and regular dealings once they are living in your property. Professionalism fosters respect and can lead to smoother interactions and resolutions of any issues that may arise. Additionally, a professional approach helps in building a positive reputation as a landlord, which can be beneficial for future tenant relationships and property management endeavors.


Finding the right tenant requires a thoughtful approach that extends beyond financial considerations. By following these tips, landlords can significantly enhance their chances of attracting and retaining ideal tenants. These strategies not only facilitate a stable and profitable rental relationship but also contribute to a positive and respectful renting environment. Implementing these tips can lead to a rewarding experience for both landlords and tenants, fostering long-term benefits for all parties involved.